Emerging Science of a High CO2/Low pH Ocean

FACE studies on land

FACE methodology has for decades been the standard for investigating the impacts of elevated atmospheric CO2 levels on terrestrial ecosystems. But this was not easily accomplished, and in order to assess the challenge we face we need to look back at the course of terrestrial ecosystem research over the last 20 years. At that time the terrestrial community faced a similar problem. It was widely believed that elevated atmospheric CO2 levels would have a positive effect on growth of land plants by facilitating entry of CO2 into the leaf stoma while minimizing water loss. But concerns over the validity of enclosed greenhouse experiments arose, and in 1985 a major review was held (US DoE, 1985) to evaluate which experimental techniques would yield the correct result for natural ecosystems.

The debate was fierce; it was estimated in one paper that for a simple forest experiment release of some 383 tons CO2 per day would be required! Yet the march of technology proceeded, designs and control systems were refined, and far more efficient studies emerged. The end result was that a large international network of experiments was created, with CO2 enrichment techniques being applied at many sites around the world through the creative endeavors of a large number of scientists. These sites do require releases of the order of hundreds of tons CO2 per year and this has been accepted as a necessary cost of uncovering the truth and predicting the future. When the results were finally synthesized 20 years after the experiments were first proposed (Long et al., 2006; Schimel, 2006) a far lower CO2 fertilization effect than first anticipated was found. Enclosed, and open, experiments can thus yield quite different results. Some 20 years later the ocean sciences face the same problem.

Two examples of FACE Experimental systems

FACE_both

FACE experiments come in many different sizes as the two examples illustrate the extremes here. On the left is an example of a Mini-FACE experiment: a 1 meter diameter ring with an array of emitters for controlling the CO2 concentration in a very small area. On the right is an example of one of the larger FACE systems showing an array of tower rings enclosing much larger areas which include many trees per each enclosure. The use of multiple enclosures allows for replication of the experiment as well as running simultaneous controls. For the development of the FOCE systems proposed by MBARI, beginning with a smaller size array offers the best route forward, but the goal of adopting a larger size framework for a true “open” system remains despite the fact that the challenges will be large.

Next:  References


Questions? Comments? Please contact Edward Peltzer.

Science

Upper-ocean systems
Biological oceanography
Global modes of sea surface temperature
Nitrate supply estimates in upwelling systems
Chemical sensors
Chemical data
Land/Ocean Biogeochemical Observatory in Elkhorn Slough
Listing of floats
SOCCOM float visualization
Periodic table of elements in the ocean
Biogeochemical-Argo Report
Profiling float
Marine microbes
Population dynamics of phytoplankton
Microbial predators
Microbe-algae interactions
Targeted metagenomics
In the news
Upcoming events and lab news
Past talks and presentations
Join the lab
Resources
Molecular ecology
Molecular systematics
SIMZ Project
Bone-eating worms
Gene flow and dispersal
Molecular-ecology expeditions
Interdisciplinary field experiments
Genomic sensors
Ocean observing system
Midwater research
Midwater ecology
Deep-sea squids and octopuses
Food web dynamics
Midwater time series
Respiration studies
Zooplankton biodiversity
Seafloor processes
Biology and ecology
Effects of humans
Ocean acidification, warming, deoxygenation
Lost shipping container study
Effects of upwelling
Faunal patterns
Past research
Technology development
High-CO2 / low-pH ocean
Benthic respirometer system
Climate change in extreme environments
Monitoring instrumentation suite
Sargasso Sea research
Antarctic research
Long-term time series
Geological changes
Arctic Shelf Edge
Continental Margins and Canyon Dynamics
Coordinated Canyon Experiment
Monterey Canyon: Stunning deep-sea topography revealed
Ocean chemistry of greenhouse gases
Emerging science of a high CO2/low pH ocean
Submarine volcanoes
Mid-ocean ridges
Magmatic processes
Volcanic processes
Explosive eruptions
Hydrothermal systems
Back arc spreading ridges
Seamounts
Near-ridge seamounts
Continental margin seamounts
Non-hot-spot linear chains
Eclectic seamounts topics
Margin processes
Hydrates and seeps
California borderland
Hot spot research
Hot-spot plumes
Magmatic processes
Volcanic processes
Explosive eruptions
Landslides
Volcanic hazards
Hydrothermal systems
Flexural arch
Coral reefs
ReefGrow software
Biogeography
Eclectic topics
Submarine volcanism cruises
Volcanoes resources
Areas of study
Biology
Microscopic biology research
Open ocean biology research
Seafloor biology research
Chemistry
Automated chemical sensors
Methane in the seafloor
Geology
Volcanoes and seamounts
Hydrothermal vents
Methane in the seafloor
Submarine canyons
Earthquakes and landslides
Ocean acidification
Physical oceanography and climate change
Ocean circulation and algal blooms
Ocean cycles and climate change
Research publications